You must use an alternative with a hardness of a lot more than seven to the Mohs scale; if not, you'll just be losing electricity by managing your tumbler. Polly Plastics sells a highly rated rock tumbler grit package and ceramic tumbling filler media (Amazon hyperlink) encouraged by many Amazon https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=pfbid0cBYku2ZfZsKExwQysMwxQWVLaaRzxn6KPz9DG8JCCiARFBfPQ8jcWQvzafLHRNEbl&id=61562415773754&__cft__[0]=AZUKzhYoPBYu64Arap6YU-1EI46p7zf3k7wgPFokdYD8_yypNsu3Q-if0gUjm5fTqbKRKbrZ0DPzi81dJnCtfoYj1YeG3b87rN_0sf5o2Uv2B7L4B58QiOKa31VTSZrlu3thAXA10m_Bd2hgpScXTk4bPC0ZSqrKO2asF_sJhTbKavJyLcszJL1hWdfejqyFlOcEKhyzOvSFGhOXXFo8Z57v&__tn__=%2CO%2CP-R